The Shopify and BigCommerce world
- Shopify and Shopify Plus
- Shopify POS
- BigCommerce
Loyalty platform comparison
Smile.io offers a points, referrals and VIP tiers programme that is easy to install and set up without code if your business sells on Shopify, Shopify Plus or BigCommerce. Its free plan includes points and referrals, while features such as the VIP programme, the API or data warehouse sync depend on your plan and monthly order volume. In physical stores it only works with Shopify POS, so it isn't designed for retailers that use other POS or ecommerce platforms.
The difference in one sentence
Smile.io is aimed at online stores on Shopify and BigCommerce looking for a loyalty programme with points, referrals and VIP tiers. Wapping extends the concept into an ecosystem of connected services, benefits and experiences for any POS and ecommerce set-up.
FROM SHOPIFY AND BIGCOMMERCE ONLY TO ANY ENVIRONMENT
Shopify is the benchmark in ecommerce, but there's much more out there. Not every online store runs on Shopify, and at the point of sale there are many other options that work very well for retailers.
- Shopify and Shopify Plus
- Shopify POS
- BigCommerce
- Shopify POS
- Odoo
- HioPOS
- ICG
- Comerzzia
- Orisha
- Powershop
- In-house POS
- ...
- Shopify
- Salesforce CC
- Magento
- Powershop
- VTEX
- WooCommerce
- Waitry
- Custom-built ecommerce
Executive summary
This first table sets out the differences that matter most when choosing a retail solution. The detailed comparison follows.
| Capability | Wapping | Smile.io |
|---|---|---|
| Retail-specific CDP | Yes | No: loyalty programme member profile |
| Basic loyalty engine | Yes | Yes: points and referrals from the free plan |
| Advanced CDP and loyalty functionality | Yes | VIP tiers (from the Growth plan), bonus points events and custom rewards |
| Real-time promotions at checkout | Yes | No: points redemption at checkout only |
| Mobile Pass for Apple Wallet and Google Wallet | Yes | Only through third-party tools |
| Customer wallet | Web, ecommerce, app, WhatsApp and Wallet | Online store (Loyalty Hub from the Growth plan) and apps via Tapcart or Makappi |
| Retail analytics and advanced segmentation | Yes | 10 to 30+ loyalty reports depending on plan, plus benchmarks |
| Native POS integrations | Yes | Shopify POS only |
| Native ecommerce integrations | Yes | Shopify, Shopify Plus and BigCommerce only |
| Security and compliance | User profiles, encryption, logs, ISO 27001 | SOC 2 Type II and Shopify Plus Security Certification |
A single platform
At Wapping, we give the marketing team the autonomy to configure the programme and launch actions without any additional set-up in the POS, ERP or ecommerce platform for each campaign.
OMNICHANNEL PROMOTION ENGINE
Create coupons and promotions on any channel for personalised audiences: 3 for 2, buy X get Y, bundles, item-level discounts or discounts on the receipt total. Attract new customers, win back lapsed ones, boost stores or off-peak hours, or drive categories as needed. Smile.io lets customers redeem points for discounts, but it doesn't include a promotion engine.
A CDP FOR RETAIL
Get a complete, unified view of your customers across every channel. Analyse omnichannel purchases and behaviour, spot sales and loyalty opportunities, and measure the real return of every campaign, promotion or service. All on a single verified customer profile, continuously enriched with every interaction.
NATIVE MOBILE PASS
Wapping natively generates the customer's card in Apple Wallet and Google Wallet, with in-store identification and push notifications. With Smile.io, Wallet cards are only available through third-party tools.
IN-HOUSE GIFT CARD
Offer omnichannel gift cards valid in store and online. Drive purchases with bonus balance, let customers send them with personalised messages and manage physical and digital formats from a single environment.
DIRECT DISCOUNT PROGRAMMES
Create incentive programmes that go beyond points. Offer exclusive discounts to customers, employees and groups, with balance control per period.
NATIVE WHATSAPP
Use WhatsApp to sign up customers and let them access their wallet, identify themselves in store with a QR code and receive campaigns, all natively integrated into Wapping. Smile.io doesn't offer WhatsApp as a native channel.
DEPOSIT CARD
Offer a Deposit Card as an alternative to a refund. The amount is loaded instantly into the customer's wallet for future purchases in store or online, bringing them back and keeping the value in your business.
PRODUCT SEGMENTATION
Create dynamic product segments by category, brand, tag or any attribute. They update automatically and can be used for promotions, cashback and personalised incentives based on the customer or the moment of purchase. Smile.io limits this control to collection-specific rewards and product exclusions.
INTERACTIVE CUSTOMER WALLET
Bring promotions, coupons, gift cards, digital receipts, points and benefits together in a single digital wallet, with a consistent experience in store, online and on mobile.
MULTICHANNEL COMMUNICATIONS
Design, automate and measure personalised communications via push, email, WhatsApp, SMS, RCS and other channels from a single platform. In Smile.io, email is native, and other channels such as SMS are enabled through integrations with other tools.
ADVANCED ANALYTICS
Analyse your business with RFM, sales by product and category, retention by sign-up date or first purchase, and service conversion by store. Use Loyalty Assistant to interpret purchases, purchase frequency, average order value, segments, campaigns and customer value, and to spot opportunities for growth, loyalty and profitability.
NATIVE CONNECTIONS WITH POS AND ECOMMERCE
Wapping offers native connectors for the leading POS and ecommerce platforms on the market, making integration easy in virtually any scenario. Smile.io only works with Shopify, Shopify Plus, Shopify POS and BigCommerce.
Artificial intelligence applied to loyalty
Loyalty Assistant lets you manage a range of Wapping functions using natural-language instructions. It knows the actions configured in the platform, interprets each request and carries out analysis, campaign activation and ROI measurement. Its capabilities expand with every new release.
Interprets dashboards and data on the business, customers and campaigns to draw useful conclusions.
Answers questions and suggests actions or campaigns based on the information available in the loyalty engine.
Creates copy and images in multiple languages and generates dynamic segments from natural-language instructions.
In-depth analysis
Here is the detailed comparison of loyalty solutions. Open each section to review CDP, loyalty, marketing, channels, integrations and security capabilities. We use the same feature table in all our comparisons, covering everything we believe a loyalty marketing platform with a CDP and an omnichannel promotion engine should offer. We don't adjust the table to suit ourselves depending on the competitor.
| Feature | Wapping | Smile.io |
|---|---|---|
| Unified online and offline customer ID | Yes | Partial: only between the online store and Shopify POS |
| Guaranteed no duplicates through mobile number verification | Yes | No |
| Explicit consent recorded from any sign-up method | Yes | No public data |
| Unified customer profile | Yes | Partial: loyalty data (points, VIP tier, referrals) |
| Full activity timeline: transactions, events and notifications | Yes | Partial: programme activity history (points and redemptions) |
| Transaction and service-usage history down to line item, total and payment method | Yes | No public data |
| Customers joining groups via code or QR code | Yes | No |
| Dynamic segmentation using more than 50 parameters | Yes | Partial: segmentation and exports on higher plans |
| Sync with PIM or product master data | Yes | No |
| Product master hierarchies, attributes and variants | Yes | No |
| Dynamic product segmentation | Yes | No |
| Criteria by category, subcategory, brand and attributes | Yes | Partial: collection-specific rewards and product exclusions |
| Business-defined event manager, usable in segmentation | Yes | Partial: custom earning actions via API |
| Feature | Wapping | Smile.io |
|---|---|---|
| Dynamic dashboards with drill-down navigation | Yes | Partial: analytics page, pre-built reports (10 to 30+ depending on plan) and financial reports |
| RFM analytics with 11 predefined segments and flexible configuration | Yes | No |
| Sales dashboard by product and category | Yes | No |
| Behaviour analysis by customer segment | Yes | Partial: VIP tier and member segment insights |
| Detailed communications dashboard for email, push, SMS and WhatsApp | Yes | No |
| Retention dashboard by sign-up date or first purchase | Yes | Partial: repeat purchase rate, ROI, CLV and benchmarks |
| Service conversion by store, profile and date | Yes | No |
| Direct export to Excel or CSV from any dashboard | Yes | Partial: full data exports |
| Custom reports exportable to Excel or CSV | Yes | Yes (Enterprise plan) |
| Sync with the business's data lake or data warehouse | Yes | Yes (Enterprise plan) |
| Feature | Wapping | Smile.io |
|---|---|---|
| Membership tiers | Yes | Yes (from the Growth plan) |
| Flexible rules for tier changes | Yes | Yes: by spend or points, calendar year or lifetime |
| Points programme | Yes | Yes |
| Tier-based points expiry | Yes | No |
| Flexible points expiry by period or time window | Yes | Partial: points expiry available depending on plan |
| Earning and redeeming points restricted by items or dates | Yes | Partial: product exclusions and bonus points events |
| Configurable delay in points activation | Yes | No public data |
| Social Points | Yes | Yes: social media and reviews |
| Strava integration | Next release | No |
| Cashback | Yes | Partial: cashback-style rewards (points redeemable for discounts or store credit) |
| Customer's choice of which cashback to redeem | Yes | Partial: customer chooses which reward to redeem |
| Direct Discount programmes | Yes | Partial: discounts as redemption or VIP tier rewards |
| Maximum discounted amount within a configurable period | Yes | No |
| Application restricted by products and dates | Yes | Partial: reward restrictions and collection-specific rewards |
| Challenges / Rewards programmes | Yes | Partial: custom ways to earn points |
| Challenges / Rewards independent of the points programme | Yes | No |
| Discount coupons | Yes | Yes: fixed amount, percentage and free shipping |
| Feature | Wapping | Smile.io |
|---|---|---|
| Real-time promotion engine for the basket, line item or payment method, with no extra configuration in the POS or ecommerce platform | Yes | No |
| Item promotions: percentage, discount, price change or extra points | Yes | No |
| Promotions on the basket total | Yes | No |
| Conditional promotions: 3 for 2 or buy X get Y | Yes | No |
| Bundle promotions | Yes | No |
| Restriction by products or product segments | Yes | No |
| Feature | Wapping | Smile.io |
|---|---|---|
| Gamification | Yes | Partial: bonus points events and nudges |
| Prize wheels | Yes | No |
| Real-time, purchase-based prize draws | Yes | No |
| Real-time prize draws via QR scan | Yes | No |
| Entry-based prize draws on a set date | Yes | Partial: contest entries as a VIP perk |
| Restriction of prize wheels or prize draws by store, date or products purchased | Yes | No |
| Stamp card | Yes | No |
| Earn & Burn programme | Yes | No |
| Catalogue products configurable as a gift | Yes | Yes: free products and exclusive products |
| Coupons and promotions configurable as a gift | Yes | Yes: discounts and free shipping |
| Third-party gift cards configurable as a gift | Yes | No |
| Third-party experiences configurable as a gift | Yes | Partial: custom rewards, such as experiences |
| Referral programme (Refer-a-Friend) | Yes | Yes, with self-referral blocking |
| Subscriptions and memberships | Yes | Partial: points and discounts for subscription orders (Recharge) |
| In-house Gift Card programme | Yes | No: points redeemable as gift cards only |
| Gift card for club members | Yes | No |
| Unregistered (bearer) gift card | Yes | No |
| Deposit Card | Yes | No |
| Digital Receipt | Yes | No |
| Promotion engine for unidentified customers | Yes | No |
| Feature | Wapping | Smile.io |
|---|---|---|
| One-to-one offer personalisation with a per-campaign budget cap | Yes | No |
| Automatic multi-language support in the customer wallet | Yes | Yes: 24 languages (English only on Shopify POS) |
| Multi-country and multi-currency operation | Yes | Partial: a single programme currency per store |
| Restriction by store or channel without automation workflows | Yes | Partial: reward online orders, in-store orders or both |
| Application by date, day and time without automation workflows | Yes | Partial: bonus points events |
| Automatic retroactive adjustment on returns | Yes | Yes: automatic points cancellation on refunds |
| Service prioritisation and incompatibility rules | Yes | No |
| Simultaneous operation of all loyalty services | Yes | Partial: points, VIP and referrals |
| Services integrated into and visible at the POS, with sales associate interaction | Yes | Partial: Shopify POS only |
| Services integrated into and visible at the ecommerce checkout | Yes | Yes: points redemption at checkout |
| Integration with any POS and ecommerce platform | Yes. Native connectors: Odoo, Shopify POS, Powershop, ICG, HioPOS, Comerzzia, Sage, Shopify, Salesforce CC, Magento, PrestaShop, VTEX and Waitry | No: only Shopify, Shopify Plus, Shopify POS and BigCommerce |
| Feature | Wapping | Smile.io |
|---|---|---|
| AI-generated campaign copy and images | Yes | No public data |
| Data interpretation in natural language | Yes | No public data |
| Segment or campaign creation in natural language | Yes | No public data |
| Automatic notifications triggered by customer events and services | Yes | Yes: programme emails |
| Scheduled notification campaigns | Yes | Partial: via Klaviyo or other integrations |
| Basic communication flows | Yes | Partial: via Klaviyo or Shopify Flow |
| Complex communication flows | No | Partial: via Klaviyo |
| Native email | Yes | Yes |
| Sending email through the customer's SMTP | Yes | Partial: all emails can be sent through Klaviyo |
| Mobile push via Mobile Pass | Yes | Partial: only through third-party tools |
| Push in an existing mobile app | Yes | No public data |
| Location-based push | No | No |
| SMS | Yes | Partial: via integrations (Klaviyo, Omnisend, Privy and others) |
| Printed receipt | Yes | No |
| Display | Yes | No |
| RCS | Yes | No |
| Native WhatsApp | Yes | No |
| In-app messaging | Yes | Partial: on-site nudges |
| Feature | Wapping | Smile.io |
|---|---|---|
| Web form | Yes | Yes: online store customer account |
| Assisted web sign-up with explicit consent | Yes | Partial: in Shopify POS, with the customer's email |
| Mobile Pass in Google Wallet and Apple Wallet | Yes | Partial: only through third-party tools |
| Yes | No | |
| Existing app or one built as part of the project | Yes | Partial: integrations with Tapcart and Makappi |
| Phone number | Yes | No public data |
| Physical card | Yes | No |
| Feature | Wapping | Smile.io |
|---|---|---|
| Cards in Google Wallet and Apple Wallet | Yes | Partial: only through third-party tools |
| Integration into an existing brand app | Yes | Partial: integrations with Tapcart and Makappi |
| Custom app for the business | Yes | No |
| Integration into the brand's online store | Yes | Yes: loyalty page, Loyalty Hub (from the Growth plan), product pages, thank-you page and checkout |
| Integration via iframe | Yes | No public data |
| Web access | Yes | Yes |
| API access with customisable front end | Yes | Yes: API (Plus plan) and JavaScript SDK |
| Content customisation from the Manager (control panel) | Yes | Yes: no-code branding |
| Loyalty notification consent management by channel | Yes | No public data |
| Store locator with map directions | Yes | No |
| Customers can turn services on or off from the wallet | Yes | No |
| Feature | Wapping | Smile.io |
|---|---|---|
| Native POS integrations | Yes | Partial: Shopify POS only |
| Native ecommerce integrations | Yes | Partial: Shopify and BigCommerce only; VIP tiers can sync to Shopify metafields |
| Integration with existing CRM or marketing automation tools | Native, webhooks, API | Yes: Klaviyo, HubSpot, Mailchimp, Dotdigital, Omnisend and more |
| REST API, webhooks and connectors | Yes | Partial: API from the Plus plan; webhooks |
| Simultaneous active integrations | Unlimited | Partial: 1 or 2 on Essential and Standard plans; unlimited from the Growth plan |
| In-store clienteling portal | Yes | No |
| Used-item take-back with a reward in points or balance | Yes | No |
| Mobile app to identify customers and let them earn benefits at events or pop-up stores | Yes | No |
| Feature | Wapping | Smile.io |
|---|---|---|
| Marketing autonomy from IT to launch any action or campaign | Yes | Yes: no-code programme set-up |
| Creation of any type of campaign without workflows | Yes | Partial: loyalty programme actions only |
| Detailed service information for customer support | Yes | Partial: customer activity and data in Gorgias and Re:amaze |
| Feature | Wapping | Smile.io |
|---|---|---|
| Manager (control panel) access with optional two-factor authentication | Yes | No public data (Shopify SSO sign-in available) |
| User roles and permissions on the platform | Yes | Yes: admin roles depending on plan |
| Automatic presentation of new versions of legal terms and consent collection | Yes | No public data |
| Notification permissions managed by channel from the wallet | Yes | No public data |
| Balance pre-authorisation at checkout to prevent fraudulent use | Yes | No |
| Alerts or blocking for suspected fraud | Yes | Partial: self-referral blocking |
| Change log per user | Yes | Yes: audit logs depending on plan |
| Data masking by user profile | Yes | No public data |
| Availability SLA | Yes, 99.95% | Partial: 99.9% stated historical uptime (Enterprise plan) |
| Security certifications: ISO 27001, SOC 2 | Yes, ISO 27001 | Yes: SOC 2 Type II and Shopify Plus Security Certification |
Integrations
The platform integrates with the leading sales systems and can work alongside the CRM or marketing automation tool the business already uses.
CDP · loyalty · omnichannel activation
Ecommerce
NativeVTEX: native connector via a partner.
Point of sale (POS)
NativeICG, HioPOS, LS Retail, Comerzzia and Sage >> native connectors through partners.
CRM / automation
Native or customWapping can work alongside your existing CRM or marketing automation tool, with the two connected to suit your requirements.
Communication Channels
ConnectedPlatform
Open architectureUnlimited simultaneous active integrations.
Selection criteria
The decision depends on your technology stack and the CDP and loyalty capabilities you need.
Smile.io may be a good fit if...
Given your size, you don't need a CDP or a promotion engine. You want to launch a points, referrals and VIP tiers programme quickly, with pricing based on your monthly order volume.
Wapping may be a good fit if...
Your POS and/or ecommerce platform don't run on Shopify or BigCommerce. You want a loyalty programme with a promotion engine and omnichannel customer services. You see personalised services, benefits and promotions as key to setting your business apart from the competition.
Frequently asked questions
At its core, Smile.io is a points, referrals and VIP tiers programme, with points redeemable for discounts, free shipping, free products or gift cards, and analytics focused on the loyalty programme. Wapping offers a broader range of loyalty features, an advanced promotion engine, a deeper CDP layer and integration with any POS and ecommerce platform.
According to its own documentation, Smile.io only works with Shopify, Shopify Plus, Shopify POS and BigCommerce. Retailers that use other POS systems, or platforms such as Magento, PrestaShop, VTEX or Salesforce Commerce Cloud, need a platform like Wapping, which offers native connectors for the leading POS and ecommerce platforms.
Because many people have several email addresses, which makes it harder to maintain unified online and offline identities, causes problems with customers in store and leads to calls to the call centre. And since creating a new email address is so easy, users may try to take advantage of new sign-up benefits. Both situations create duplicates and unreliable data.
Wapping uses the customer's mobile number as the unique identifier and verifies it at sign-up. This creates a unique customer identity without merge and curation processes, guaranteeing no duplicates and strict GDPR compliance.
No. Mobile Passes are a good option, but if the business has an app, customers should be able to identify themselves with it, as well as via WhatsApp and, in some businesses, even with a physical card for older customers who don't use a smartphone.
Because points, cashback and gifts are reward mechanisms, not necessarily activation mechanisms. Wapping doesn't just build customer loyalty: it also provides tools to drive sales, steer demand and run omnichannel commercial strategies from the same platform.
Wapping processes each customer's active benefits in real time according to the store, items, date and time, and applies them all at once at checkout, showing every benefit on the final receipt. The marketing team has full autonomy to launch, in minutes and across all channels, any promotion, campaign or loyalty service without any additional configuration in the POS, ERP or ecommerce platform.
See Wapping in action
We'll show you how to bring customer identification, data, benefits and omnichannel execution together on a single platform.
Last updated: 30 October 2026. Smile.io data based on its official website (smile.io), pricing page and help centre (help.smile.io). If you spot any incorrect information, email us at info@wappingweb.com